There are always brand-new proposals for big-money framework projects, yet could these 5 really change life in Britain and also Ireland?


On Tuesday, we disputed proposals for a new road Channel tunnel, a motorway for east Britain, a leg to the Isle that Wight, billion-pound tram schemes and a tunnel in ~ Welwyn North.


A tunnel or bridge in between Britain and Ireland has actually been disputed for decades. It would rise tourism and business activity on both political parties of the irish Sea, pendant argue. Yet what about the engineering?


\"*\"
image source, Getty Images

Bridges are typically cheaper. But a UK-Ireland bridge would have to be long. Donghai leg at 20.2 mile linking Shanghai and also offshore Yangshan is sometimes called the longest sea bridge. In the many realistic locations, a bridge to north Ireland or the Republic would certainly be even longer.

You are watching: How far is wales from ireland


A 21-mile leg from Galloway in Scotland to northern Ireland was proposed in 2007. Think-tank the Centre because that Cross Border Studies put forward the proposal to administer international rail web links that could contend with waiting services.


The Chambers of commerce of Ireland referred to as in 2005 for a component tunnel, part bridge link to lug trains between Tuskar, county Wexford, in Ireland and Pembrokeshire in Wales. Three-quarters of ireland firms surveyed at the time said that a fixed connect with Europe was vital.


The ireland Academy of engineers has envisaged a 50-mile rail tunnel through a journey time indigenous Dublin to Pembrokeshire the 70 minutes.


Four main routes have been proposed. Two run from Scotland to northern Ireland - Campbeltown to county Antrim, or Stranraer come Belfast.

See more: How Much Is 25 Ounces In Cups ? 25 Ounces To Cups


Two run from Wales come the Republic, a northern and southern route, whereby the Welsh peninsula juts right into the irish Sea.


Bill Grose, former chairman the the brother Tunnelling Society, says there are two crucial issues because that siting the tunnel. First, the ar that most supports transfer demand, and also how well served that location is by rail and also road links. Second, the shortest distance throughout the sea.


Holyhead come Dublin is about 50 miles of water, Fishguard to Wexford is around 45 miles and also Stranraer come Belfast is about 20 miles.


The Campbeltown to county Antrim path is only 12 miles yet the town is in an isolated component of Scotland the would require transport web links to be reduced through like the mountain terrain.


The many financially viable appear to it is in those indigenous Wales to the Republic, Grose says. \"Intuitively Holyhead come Dublin is a an ext preferable path than the others. It's closer come Manchester and also Liverpool and connects straight right into Dublin.\"


Rail rather than road would be more realistic both financially and also from an engineering suggest of view, that says. Rail tunnels cost about £60m a kilometre (accounting for one tunnel in every direction).


Road tunnels must be about 50% bigger and also a tunnel in between Holyhead and Dublin would need a ventilation island halfway, which would not it is in cheap. With the Channel Tunnel historically struggling to make money ~ above a lot bigger catchment area - the UK and continental Europe - many will doubt whether over there is yes, really the business case because that the tunnel.


Also the benefits would certainly be much better in Ireland, i beg your pardon would obtain a through-route to continent Europe, 보다 in Britain, which would only gain a path to Ireland. The Irish government would be called on to provide at least fifty percent the cost, other that can seem i can not qualify in these straitened times.


\"*\"
image source, Foster + Partners
\"*\"
image source, PA
\"*\"
image source, Getty Images
\"*\"
image source, PA