Invading predators can devastate an ecosystem. In fact, a leading cause of extinct is the development of predators into an isolated mechanism like one island or a lake. The destruction is normally blamed on the predator’s eat choices, however sometimes the an essential lies in the prey animals’ responses, according to an worldwide team of researchers led by’s Robert Pringle.

You are watching: How does predation cause stability in an ecosystem apex

“You really can’t understand predator-prey interactions — or exactly how predators will influence biodiversity and ecosystems — without understanding the behavior of the prey,” stated Pringle, an associate professor that ecology and also evolutionary biology. “The methods in i beg your pardon prey adjust their habits to protect against getting consumed is a difficult thing come predict, yet without understanding that, you can not predict noþeles else. Many theory in ecology merely assumes the predators eat prey, finish of story. The real people is more complicated. But it’s no so complex that us can’t acquire to the bottom the it.”


To research the results of invading predators, a research team led by"s plunder Pringle supplied three lizard species: one predator, the curly-tailed lizard (Leiocephalus carinatus, bottom left), and also two prey species, environment-friendly anoles (Anolis smaragdinus, top) and also brown anoles (Anolis sagrei, bottom right). They found that the anoles might coexist peacefully, with green anoles in the trees and brown anoles closer come the ground, but introducing predators journey the brown anoles right into the trees, intensifying competition and undermining their ability to coexist. Their results therefore difficulty the generality the the keystone-predation hypothesis and support refuge competition.

Photos by Jonathan Losos, Washington university (bottom right) and also Kiyoko Gotanda, McGill university (bottom left and also top)

The inquiry is swiftly becoming an ext pressing, listed co-author Rowan Barrett, the Canada research study Chair that Biodiversity scientific research at McGill university in Montreal, Quebec. “Human activity is boosting the incident of brand-new predators being introduced to formerly isolated ecosystems,” he said. “Our work shows the the consequences of these predator intrusions for biodiversity deserve to depend strong on transforms in prey behavior that change the method prey varieties use their environments.”

To handle the question, the team offered three lizard species: one predator, the curly-tailed lizard Leiocephalus carinatus, and also two food species, eco-friendly anoles (Anolis smaragdinus) and brown anoles (Anolis sagrei). Their results appear in the June 6 concern of Nature.

The researchers traveled come 16 little islands in the Bahamas the they offered as speculative ecosystems. The brown anoles were created on all 16, and also the researchers presented the various other two lizards individually or in combination.

“It’s so rarely in ecology to have the ability to manipulate entirety ecosystems — these tiny islands are kind of like huge oceanic petri bowl that permit us to run really tight and compelling experiments,” Pringle said. “It’s just not feasible to carry out that in many places.”


Rob Pringle (left) and Arash Askary of mcgill University search a Bahama island for lizards to collect fecal samples because that DNA metabarcoding. Pringle very first conceived of this 16-island experiment in 2010 and also introduced the green anoles (prey) and curly-tailed lizards (predators) in different combinations in 2011. He had actually a brief panic in 2013 once it looked like the environment-friendly anoles would certainly not establish populations on any kind of of the islands. “I was really relieved when, in 2014, we began to see the pattern emerging, v the eco-friendly anole populations exploding, yet only on the islands there is no curly-tailed lizards.”

The researchers found that in the lack of predators, the two anole species coexisted simply fine, with eco-friendly anoles in trees and brown anoles living closer come the ground. The two types competed for insects, yet the competition to be “not severe,” Pringle said. However when the team introduced the curly-tailed predators, the brown anoles fled to the trees, wherein the chunky ground-dwelling lizard couldn’t follow. This increase the competition between the two prey varieties for an are and food, which undermined their capability to coexist. The results suggest that once prey have the right to respond swiftly to the existence of a predator by transforming their behavior, predators might commonly reduce the ability of prey species to coexist.

“One the the vital implications of our examine is the the size of the refuges the prey have from predators deserve to be really necessary for ensuring that food don’t go extinct,” said Todd Palmer, a co-first-author in ~ the college of Florida. “When yes sir not enough room for food to hang the end without the continuous risk of being eaten, something’s got to give, and that’s once we see species disappearing. Few of the an ext recent examples of catastrophic varieties extinction, such as the please of a really diverse group the fish species in the African an excellent lakes, might have emerged in part because there just wasn’t enough safe room in those ecosystems. For this reason our findings not only provide us part clues about how to manage future predator introductions, but also a much better understanding of how past extinctions might have emerged as well.”


Researchers walk in between islands at short tide. Indigenous left: josh Daskin, Ph.D. 2017; Pringle; Naomi guy in’t Veld of mc glitter University; and also Tyler Kartzinel, a former postdoctoral study associate in Pringle’s lab.

This research study “provides a beautiful counterexample to a classic ecology theory,” claimed Gaku Takimoto, a theoretical ecologist in ~ the college of Tokyo that was not affiliated in the research. “In theory, predation promotes the coexistence of competing prey types by crushing premium competitors and siding v inferior competitors, yet their experiment showed that threat of predation brought about a superior contender to transition its habitat come usurp that of weaker competitors and also destroy your coexistence.”

Scientists have actually long known how crucial “keystone predators” deserve to be for healthy and balanced ecosystems. Follow to the keystone predator theory, height predators deserve to prevent any kind of one prey varieties from becoming too abundant and also outcompeting all the other prey species, i m sorry should generally increase the diversity that the species at low levels of the food chain. While this research does no overturn this concept, it does highlight that an ecosystem v a top predator will not have to be much more diverse than one without a peak predator.

“Predators deserve to reduce the diversity of food species,” claimed Pringle. “That’s not ‘good,’ and it’s not ‘bad’ — the is what the is. The crucial thing come me is the we understand how and why predators have actually the effects that they do, so the we can predict what will happen when ecosystems gain new predators through intrusions or once they shed existing predators through extinctions. That is really what our examine was aiming to do. It’s no a morality play. Yes no an excellent and no evil. We’re simply trying to obtain a clear understanding of the biology.”

Scientists quiet don’t fully understand all the ways presented predators impact resident prey species. In some cases, the course, an presented predator deserve to devastate prey populations by just eating them up. However prey can additionally respond come predators in means that alleviate their likelihood the getting eaten — prefer hiding in trees, as the brown anoles did. There, the threat of predation is low, however then these locations become crowded, and also competition becomes intense. This leads to the opposite result from the timeless keystone predation scenario; Pringle’s team dubbed it “refuge competition.”

“After 6 years of population monitoring, we uncovered that curly-tailed lizards destabilized coexistence the the contending prey varieties by forcing brown and also green anoles come share the exact same predator-free refuges and also intensifying competition between them, bring about the die out of some populations,” stated McGill’s Barrett. Their outcomes therefore an obstacle the generality of the keystone-predation hypothesis and support the refuge-competition hypothesis in this environment, he said.


Man in ’t Veld conducts a lizard census through a squirt bottle full of red paint. The ar work was no the tropical vacation that many imagine, Pringle said. “You tell people that you have actually a research job in the Bahamas, and practically everybody has actually this sarcastic reaction — ‘Oh, difficult life!’ however the fact is, this project has actually been the most grueling, most uncomfortable and physically demanding job-related I’ve ever done: crawling approximately on ours hands, knees and bellies with really special vegetation on really sharp limestone rocks in 90-degree heat. We had lots the cuts and bruises. Several of us gained stitches. I’m definitely not complaining. We’re so happy to have the ability to do work-related in the ar anywhere, and also this is not just a spectacularly beautiful place, but additionally one that provides unique methods to execute really elegant experimental research. It’s to be a blast. But it’s constantly been funny to me, the contrast in between what human being imagine when you say the you job-related in the Bahamas and also the nature of what the work is really like.”

The researchers wanted to destruction deeper than simple populace surveys, therefore they carried out DNA metabarcoding top top fecal samples from every lizard species, to analyze their diets. DNA metabarcoding, a powerful tool the uses short fragments that fecal DNA to determine the prey species eaten by a predator, showed how the lizard species were completing for food top top the islands. The researchers likewise used stable-isotope analysis to analyze exactly how the experimental treatments influenced the length of the food chain on the islands and also the position of each varieties in the food chain. 

Taken together, this techniques permitted the researchers to understand their outcomes much much more deeply, claimed Pringle. “A most times, you’ll run an experiment in the field and get part results, but you won’t necessarily recognize why you acquired those outcomes — you can have a ideal guess or a favored hypothesis, however it’s regularly a little bit ambiguous,” he said. “It’s to be a score of mine because that a lengthy time to integrate brand-new techniques favor DNA metabarcoding with developed techniques choose muddy-boots field experiments to shot to get more insight right into mechanism. In this study, we really wove all these aspects together over the food of the six-year experiment, and also that is an extremely satisfying.”

Pringle share co-first-authorship with Tyler Kartzinel, a former postdoc in his lab that is currently at Brown University, and also with UF’s Palmer. Other co-authors room graduate college student Matthew Hutchinson and also graduate alumni Tyler Coverdale (Ph.D. 2018) and also Josh Dakin (Ph.D. 2017). Undergraduate Lauren Wyman (Class the 2014) contributed to the fieldwork, and also she and Annie Ferlmann (Class of 2016) both did an elderly theses using data native this project.

See more: How Long Is Flight From Hawaii To Japan Flight Duration, Travel Time From Honolulu To Tokyo

“Dr. Pringle was able to mimic naturally developing introductions of new competitors and predators and also then track what happens in genuine time,” stated Jodie Jawor, a regime director at the national Science Foundation, which funded this research. “This is a rarely and beneficial test that what happens to areas when brand-new species are introduced. … Habitats and the ingredient of animal communities can adjust for assorted reasons — natural disasters, development, building and construction — for this reason this work helps us understand the eco-friendly impacts and also potentially resolve them proactively and more fully informed.” 

“Predator-induced fallen of niche structure and species coexistence,” by Robert M. Pringle, Tyler R. Kartzinel, Todd M. Palmer, Timothy J. Thurman, Kena Fox-Dobbs, Charles C. Y. Xu, Matthew C. Hutchinson, Tyler C. Coverdale, Joshua H. Daskin, Dominic A. Evangelista, Kiyoko M. Gotanda, Naomi A. Guy in ’t Veld, Johanna E. Wegener, Jason J. Kolbe, thomas W. Schoener, David A. Spiller, Jonathan B. Losos & Rowan D. H. Barrett, appears in the June 6 concern of Nature (DOI: 10.1038/s41586-019-1264-6). The study was sustained by the joined States nationwide Science structure (grant DEB-1457697), the eco-friendly Institute, a Canada research Chair, and a Vanier Canada Scholarship native the natural Sciences and also Engineering research study Council of Canada.